The Smile That Stayed by Siobhan Ni Mhathuna

Published on 24 November 2025 at 14:36

Siobhan sat alone in her softly lit living room, a cup of chamomile tea cradled in her hands and the gentle hum of the fan barely louder than her own breath. The photo sat on the coffee table before her—a glossy print, newly delivered, taken just a few days ago.


She picked it up again, studying every inch of it. Her wide smile was almost defiant, the kind that said “I’m finally here.” Her eyes sparkled behind thick lashes, and her long blonde hair—dyed a few months back but somehow perfectly hers—curled playfully around her shoulders. She wore a flowing floral dress, her favourite one, and heels that had once terrified her but now made her feel grounded. The joy in the photo was unmistakable. Unapologetic. Free.


Siobhan traced the edges of the picture with her fingers, holding it gently like a precious secret. Then, as if stirred by some instinct, she reached for the old shoebox tucked beneath the coffee table. It was battered and half-forgotten, filled with fading photographs, drawings, and memories no one ever asked her about.


She rummaged through it slowly, careful not to tear anything. And then she found it.


A tiny square photo, almost sepia with age. A two-year-old child with bright eyes and impossibly long blonde hair grinned back at her. She was wearing a white cotton vest with frilly trim and matching knickers—hand-me-downs from an older sister. Too young to know what she was wearing, too young to understand why it felt so right.
Siobhan stared at the photo for a long time.


The child's smile was wide, mischievous, open. And suddenly, like an old lock turning easily after years of rust, something inside her clicked into place. She held both pictures side by side—two versions of herself separated by five decades but connected by the same light in the eyes, the same unshakable joy, the same hair, the same smile.


She hadn’t realized how much she’d needed this moment. To see proof that she hadn’t become someone new—she’d simply returned to who she’d been all along. Hidden, paused, waiting patiently beneath the surface.


Tears welled in her eyes but didn’t fall. She wasn’t sad. She was full—with gratitude, with clarity, with peace.


Fifty years had passed between those two photos. Half a century of pretending, surviving, managing. But here she was now, dressed how she wanted, smiling without shame, seeing herself reflected not just in the mirror—but in the child she had once been.


"She knew," Siobhan whispered. "Even then, she knew."
She leaned back into the couch, the two photos still in her lap, and closed her eyes. That smile—her smile—had never left. It had just been waiting for her to catch up.


Add comment

Comments

There are no comments yet.